Marcal Pro Floors vs Santa Rosa Tile Installation: which for a kitchen backsplash?
Both of these Tampa contractors score at the top of our methodology, so a kitchen backsplash job comes down to team size and how each shop handles a project this scale versus their bigger jobs. Here's what actually separates them for a backsplash.
The differences that matter
- Team depth vs. single lead. Marcal Pro Floors runs a larger named crew (Felipe, Henrick, Bruno, Israel, Alexis), while Santa Rosa is built around Petre personally leading every job.
- Scale of typical projects. Marcal Pro Floors' reviews lean toward full flooring and tile projects including complex removals, while Santa Rosa's praise specifically calls out backsplashes as a common, well-handled job size.
- Fixing prior contractor mistakes. Santa Rosa's data specifically notes a track record of correcting previous contractors' errors, which matters if you're redoing a botched backsplash.
- Review volume and track record. Marcal Pro Floors has more reviews (143 vs 115) and a slightly higher composite score, giving it a bit more data-backed confidence.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Marcal Pro Floors Kitchen & Bath: 5 (143 reviews)
- Santa Rosa Tile Installation: 5 (115 reviews)
- Services
- Marcal Pro Floors Kitchen & Bath: tile installation, kitchen backsplash tile, bathroom shower tile
- Santa Rosa Tile Installation: tile installation, bathroom shower tile, kitchen backsplash tile
- Best for small, standalone jobs
- Marcal Pro Floors Kitchen & Bath: Good fit, but reviews skew toward larger flooring/tile projects
- Santa Rosa Tile Installation: Strong fit, backsplashes specifically called out as routine work
- Best for redo/correction work
- Marcal Pro Floors Kitchen & Bath: Not specifically mentioned in the data
- Santa Rosa Tile Installation: Specifically praised for correcting prior contractor mistakes
- Point of contact
- Marcal Pro Floors Kitchen & Bath: Multiple named installers and project managers
- Santa Rosa Tile Installation: Single lead technician (Petre) on all major jobs
- Verification
- Marcal Pro Floors Kitchen & Bath: Google-verified
- Santa Rosa Tile Installation: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Marcal Pro Floors Kitchen & Bath: 93
- Santa Rosa Tile Installation: 92
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Marcal Pro Floors Kitchen & Bath
Felipe, Henrick, and their crews deliver consistent, detail-oriented work across flooring and tile projects. Reviewers highlight clear communication at each phase, fair pricing, efficient timelines, and spotless cleanup. Multiple repeat customers credit reliable scheduling and skilled installers who respect the home and finish projects ahead of holidays or deadlines.
Named staff including Bruno, Israel, and Alexis appear regularly in praise for material knowledge, professionalism, and workmanship. The team stores materials on-site during projects, move furniture carefully, and handle complex removals like water-damaged floors with competence and courtesy.
Santa Rosa Tile Installation
Reviewers consistently report flawless tile work and responsive service. Petre and his crew handle everything from backsplashes to full bathroom retiles with visible care for the finished look, rarely leaving a homeowner without plans to rehire them.
Which should you pick?
Pick Marcal Pro Floors Kitchen & Bath if
- You want a bigger crew with named specialists and material-handling systems already in place
- Your project might expand beyond the backsplash into other flooring or tile work
- You value a slightly larger review history (143 reviews) backing the score
Pick Santa Rosa Tile Installation if
- You're doing a standalone backsplash and want a contractor whose reviews specifically call that out as core work
- You're fixing tile a previous contractor botched
- You prefer one consistent lead (Petre) overseeing the job start to finish
Verdict
For a kitchen backsplash specifically, Santa Rosa Tile Installation has the edge on fit: its review data explicitly names backsplashes as routine work and highlights fixing other contractors' mistakes, both directly relevant to a smaller, standalone tile job. Marcal Pro Floors is the stronger pick if you want a larger team with more reviews behind it or expect the project to grow into broader flooring or tile work beyond just the backsplash.
Still looking for the right tile contractor?
Describe your project once and request quotes from qualified tile contractor in Tampa Fl.
When you submit a contact form on this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work. We may receive a referral fee for this, but our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method and are never influenced by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which business has more experience specifically with backsplashes?
- Santa Rosa Tile Installation's review data calls out backsplashes by name as a job type they handle regularly and well, from single backsplashes through full bathroom retiles.
- Which has the higher composite score?
- Marcal Pro Floors scores 92.6 versus Santa Rosa's 91.6, with Marcal also having more reviews (143 vs 115), giving it a marginally higher confidence rating.
- Who should I pick if a previous contractor did a bad job on my backsplash?
- Santa Rosa Tile Installation's data specifically notes a history of correcting previous contractors' mistakes without complaint.